Welcome to Cottage Cafe Middletown
Cottage Cafe Middletown, located at 11609 Main St, is a charming lunch destination known for its delightful food and warm service. Operating from 11 AM to 3 PM, this cozy eatery offers a simple yet enticing menu featuring soups, sandwiches, and scrumptious desserts, including the much-praised orange dreamsicle cheesecake and decadent marbled cake. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes and the welcoming atmosphere, with staff members consistently praised for their attentiveness. From their signature bacon and benedictine sandwich to homemade cakes crafted with care, Cottage Cafe captures the essence of comfort food, making it a must-visit local gem.
Cottage Cafe Middletown: Reviews & Ratings
Wonderful lunch spot, only open from 11 to 3 , take the alley and park in the back, the entrance is in the back. Lunch specials every day, and a small menu, soup, sandwiches, and wonderful dessert place. We had the bacon and benedictine sandwich, deviled eggs, and a hot brown. The a huge piece of marbled cake and coconut pie. The food was large portions and outstanding! I took the chicken salad.and cake home!! Will definitely go back!
“ Strawberry cake , deviled eggs, potato salad & tomato dill soup “ were delicious ! I attended a lunch here yesterday for the first time ! Food was very tasty ! Staff was very kind ! Service was very quick especially for our large group !
BIG, BIG SHOUT OUT to Cottage Cafe!!! Susie and her staff are absolutely amazing! I called Susie on Thursday to see if she could make an oreo birthday cake that our son requested. She did absolutely an amazing job on such short notice. Cottage Cafe will be my go to for our birthday cakes for now on! It’s homemade from scratch with real whipping cream. It’s huge and so moist - I can go on and on. If you haven’t visited Cottage Cafe in downtown old Middletown go. Thank you Susie!
I loved having lunch at this little cottage! The service was outstanding and everyone was so friendly and attentive. Food came out fast and fantastic sandwiches and salads! Loved the chicken salad sandwich and they did not shy away from the meat! But let’s talk about the real gem of this place...the dessert! Oh my heavenly goodness! Lots of mouthwatering options! I opted for the orange dreamsicle cheesecake and it was delightful! Will definitely eat here again!
My partner and I went into Cottage Cafe on a whim and we’re so glad we did! The service was fantastic, and our food arrived to our table super quickly. We left with the last slice of coconut cream pie (it was delicious). We will definitely be back!
Absolutely amazing cakes and pies. Some recipes passed down from generation to generation. The best kept secret in Middletown, KY. This little cafe is run by the sweetest family. Their homemade chicken salad is scrumptious. Light yet tasty and filling. I can't tell you in words alone how decadent everything we purchased and tried was. Highly recommend going to eat here or picking up a nice desert. We purchased the strawberry jelly cake roll. Oh my it was melt in your mouth. If you want a cute story ask about the flamingos! I met Rachael and her mom and they are some really good people. They put their all into their products and reputation. Support you local small businesses but also worth the drive if you aren't local.
Home-made food with specials. Thursday & Saturday Hot Browns a Kentucky delicacy. Scrumptious desserts made by Sue always in the glass showcase. We really enjoyed meeting the owner & staff.
The Cottage Cafe made for a great stop for lunch. I had a cup of the tomato dill soup, which had a great combination of flavors, and the Benedictine sandwich. The sandwich was colorful and had lots of cucumber flavor. Having never tried this type of sandwich before, it was a great surprise. The place is wonderful with lots of southern charm. The staff was friendly and quick to take my order. This is the kind of place I’d imagine is a local treasure. Definitely worth a visit.
Location
-
11609 Main St, Middletown, KY 40243, United States Hotline: +1 502-244-9497
If you find yourself meandering along Main Street in Middletown, Kentucky, a hidden gem awaits you at Cottage Cafe Middletown. Tucked away behind an unassuming alley, this quaint eatery invites you in for a delightful lunch experience, open from 11 AM to 3 PM. It's a special spot praised for its welcoming ambiance and a charming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home.
With a menu that focuses on the essentials—think soups, sandwiches, and divine desserts—Cottage Cafe stands out for its lunch specials that change every day. Patrons rave about signature dishes like the bacon and benedictine sandwich and deviled eggs. These comforting selections are paired beautifully with rich, flavorful options such as tomato dill soup and the unforgettable hot brown.
One of the cafe's shining traits is its desserts; the reviews speak for themselves. Guests have left with slices of marbled cake, coconut cream pie, and even orange dreamsicle cheesecake, all made from scratch with utmost care. Feedback highlights the generous portion sizes, ensuring you leave satisfied or with a delicious treat for later. As one visitor mentioned, they simply couldn't resist taking home the chicken salad sandwich and a slice of cake—evidence of the delightful flavors that linger long after the meal.
The service at Cottage Cafe is equally commendable. Frequent feedback from patrons emphasizes the attentive and friendly staff, who create an inviting environment perfect for both small gatherings and larger groups alike. As Kerri Beyer noted, they accommodate special requests—like custom birthday cakes—effortlessly and on short notice, showcasing their commitment to providing excellent service.
Whether you're a local looking for a new regular lunch spot or just passing through, Cottage Cafe Middletown is a must-visit. Allow yourself to be enchanted by the cozy vibe, top-notch food, and the kind of hospitality that makes you feel like part of the family. I can’t wait to return and explore more of their delightful offerings!
For more information, contact them at +1 502-244-9497 and plan your visit to 11609 Main St, Middletown, KY 40243, United States.